Friday, October 10, 2008

David Brooks Discovers The Class War

In his Op-Ed article today, David Brooks calls out Sarah Palin for being unabashedly anti-intellectual:

Palin is smart, politically skilled, courageous and likable. Her convention and debate performances were impressive. But no American politician plays the class-warfare card as constantly as Palin. Nobody so relentlessly divides the world between the “normal Joe Sixpack American” and the coastal elite.

She is another step in the Republican change of personality. Once conservatives admired Churchill and Lincoln above all — men from wildly different backgrounds who prepared for leadership through constant reading, historical understanding and sophisticated thinking. Now those attributes bow down before the common touch

Anti-intellectualism and anti-sophistication have been the hallmarks of the mainstream conservative movement for the last decade. Indeed, David Brooks knows this very well, as he wrote an article, in the Atlantic, no less, mocking coastal sophisticates. A sample:
We in the coastal metro Blue areas read more books and attend more plays than the people in the Red heartland. We're more sophisticated and cosmopolitan—just ask us about our alumni trips to China or Provence, or our interest in Buddhism. But don't ask us, please, what life in Red America is like. We don't know. We don't know who Tim LaHaye and Jerry B. Jenkins are, even though the novels they have co-written have sold about 40 million copies over the past few years. We don't know what James Dobson says on his radio program, which is listened to by millions. We don't know about Reba or Travis. (his links.)
Now, eight years later, when the fruit of what he has sown has been reaped in Sarah Palin's ascendancy to a nominee for Vice President, he has changed his tune:

Over the past 15 years, the same argument has been heard from a thousand politicians and a hundred television and talk-radio jocks. The nation is divided between the wholesome Joe Sixpacks in the heartland and the oversophisticated, overeducated, oversecularized denizens of the coasts.

What had been a disdain for liberal intellectuals slipped into a disdain for the educated class as a whole. The liberals had coastal condescension, so the conservatives developed their own anti-elitism, with mirror-image categories and mirror-image resentments, but with the same corrosive effect.

What caused this change? Brooks wrote the Atlantic article right after the election of George W. Bush, who, of course, came from an East Coast elite family and had an Ivy Leage education. He played the role of "middle American", but really, he was, like Brooks, a highly educated man and his administration was filled with men who went to Ivy League Schools. Bush, Cheney, and Ashcroft all attended Yale, with Cheney the only one who didn't graduate from there. Scooter Libby also is a Yale graduate. Donald Rumsfeld graduated from Princeton, Paul Wolfowitz from Cornell, and Tom Ridge from Harvard. In short, while the administration represented "Joe Sixpack", they were not Joe Sixpack and they had traditional "elitist" educations.

However, Sarah Palin does not fit this bill. While the Bush administration paid lip service to anti-intellectualism, Sarah Palin has lived it. She bounced around from college to college, finally graduating with a degree in Communications-Journalism and becoming a sportscaster. Prior to her nomination as Vice President, she displayed no interest in foreign policy, and since her nomination has frequently demonstrated her lack of understanding of what her party's platform is, let alone a grasp on what the issues are.

Brooks is not a stupid man. He understands the dangers that come with having an uneducated person a heartbeat away from being the most powerful person in the world. And what intellectual honesty he has forces him to report on this. However, by reporting on this, he is admitting his compliancy in the demonization of education and is, in part, intellectually responsible a potential Palin presidency.

A Recapitalization Plan

Greg Mankiw:
Here is an idea that might deal with these problems: The government can stand ready to be a silent partner to future Warren Buffetts.

It could work as follows. Whenever any financial institution attracts new private capital in an arms-length transaction, it can access an equal amount of public capital. The taxpayer would get the same terms as the private investor. The only difference is that government’s shares would be nonvoting until the government sold the shares at a later date.

This plan would solve the three problems. The private sector rather than the government would weed out the zombie firms. The private sector rather than the government would set the price. And the private sector rather than the government would exercise corporate control.


This would be an interesting compromise between the private and public sectors fixing the current crisis. It would encourage private investors to get involved because they'd have to put up less money, and it would prevent an overreaching government ownership over banks.

Wednesday, October 8, 2008

Economic Crisis: What To Do

The short version is that I don't know what to do. I don't think most people have any idea. There's no way of telling, for sure, how bad things will get. The major players certainly aren't going to tell us how bad things are or might become. Doing so would risk scaring the crap out of the average person, and this loss of confidence would make all the problems we have now even worse. So the Powers That Be (people like Bernanke, Paulson, etc) are walking a tight rope between letting us know the gist of what's happening and not allowing the public to create a panic that makes things worse.

So what do we do? Again, I don't really know. I think the best thing we can do is just try to go about our business and do as much of what we would normally do which is fiscally responsible for us. At the same time, we should make some slight changes in our daily routine: try to drive less and take public transit or car pool more, don't buy things on credit, and perhaps save more of our disposable income. Most importantly, we can't allow ourselves to panic and try to pull our assets out. That'll only exacerbate the problem.

Tuesday, October 7, 2008

"That One"

I couldn't really figure out what McCain was thinking when he referred to Obama as "that one". I couldn't think of a way that it would be racist. Still, it exuded contempt. Was it a shot at Oprah declaring Obama "The One"? Was McCain just cranky?

Either way, it was classless and uncivil. Not something you want to see in a debate from somebody who could become the most powerful man in the world in a little more than three months. And, while this might be a mental revision on my part, it made George W. Bush's performances a little less loathsome.

Fact Checks

See ThinkProgress's liveblogging for fact checks.

Debate Reaction

Here are some thoughts on the debate:

  • A spending freeze across the board. As Matt explained after the last debate, this won't help, but rather hurt. It would remove money from the economy and slow it down.
  • Obama calling out Bush for telling people to go shopping after 9/11. Point made, I guess, it isn't that much of a sacrifice. But it really missed the point of what Bush was saying. He meant that the worst thing Americans could do after the attacks is stay at home and allow their daily routines to be interrupted. His point was "don't be afraid." And I think that's a fair request following the attacks.
  • When asked about what sacrifices they would ask Americans to make, McCain repeated a bunch of talking points. Obama was able to elaborate and list how he would ask Americans to sacrifice.
  • McCain gaffe. He says that the last President to raise taxes was Herbet Hoover in 1929. Well, aside from the semantics that the President doesn't actually raise taxes, his larger point is also not true. Bill Clinton raised taxes early in his first term, and the economy experienced one of the largest periods of growth in US history. (via thinkprogress)
  • Early in the debate, McCain mentioned that the next generation was going to be saddled with trillions of dollars in debt. But he doesn’t want to raise taxes. How else are we going to pay down this debt if we don't raise taxes? Is there another option that I'm not aware of?
  • McCain talking about Reagan and Tip O'Neill fell flat. Both men have passed away, and McCain is facing questions about whether he is too old or could pass away in office.
  • It seemed as though McCain was confusing Hillary's healthcare plan with Obama's. Hillary's had mandates for everybody and fines. Obama only mandates for children. And I don't think that's a bad thing.
  • Nice Obama pivot on whether he is unserious and dangerous in foreign policy.
  • The Obama Doctrine: It seemed a little muddled at first, but then his answer cleared up. There is a moral obligation to prevent genocides, but we must do so with a strong coalition. Decent answer. The McCain Doctrine: Obama was wrong on the surge and won't admit it. Also, what Obama said.
  • Israel/Iran: It seems to me (and I know this could be naive on my part) that it is presumptuous of us to think that the Israelis would need our help in the event of an attack. They haven't yet needed one, and they still have, by far, the most powerful military in the Middle East. Also, there is no real way for Iranian forces to reach Israel. This means that the only way for the Iranian military to attack would to be with bombs. The presumption here is that the bombs would be nukes. But, despite the unhinged rhetoric, Iran is not stupid. They do not currently have a nuclear arsenel. Israel most likely does. Should they obtain one, it still wouldn't match Israels. Or a probable US response. Please see MAD. Furthermore, I think an Israeli attack to prevent Iran from acquiring nukes is more likely than a surprise Iran nuclear attack. That being said, we should always be willing to support any ally that has been attacked.

Wednesday, October 1, 2008

Foreign Policy Challenges

The next president, whoever it will be, will face a myriad of foreign policy challenges that must be addressed, probably by this time next year. It’s worth exploring all of these issues, but that would make for a very long post. So what I’m going to do is list the major challenges followed by a brief explanation, and then in the weeks leading up to the election, analyze each individual issue in detail.

Of course, this is by no means a list of the only foreign policy challenges the next president will face. Certainly, there are more challenges than could be easily listed. And there’s always a good possibility that a new challenge will emerge in the next four years. However, I’m not in the business of speculating (or wars of prevention), so I’m not going to look for problems where right now there are none. I also realize that there may be some who don’t believe that something I’ve listed is a challenge. That’s fine, too. I’m just calling what I see. So, in no particular order:

  1. Iraq − While there has been a lot of progress in the last two years, the next president will have to see continued progress and decide the fate of the troops and decide what exactly our strategy is.
  2. China − The world’s fastest growing economy and largest population. This has given them added confidence in world affairs. An upshot is, aside from selling arms to nations that are hostile to the US, they usually keep to themselves on many matters before the international community. The downside of this, however, is that they generally keep out of matters before the international community, such as the recent problems in Burma.
  3. Iran − As the country tries to go nuclear, its President, who yields very little actual power, cranks up the anti−American and Israeli rhetoric. They also have, at the very least, projected some of their influence into Iraq. However, the government rules over a relatively modern society that does not necessarily follow lockstep with the government.
  4. Russia − After eight years as president and unable to run for election again, Vladimir Putin finds himself the…Prime Minister of Russia. Russia under Putin has become an aggressive state fueled on Petrol dollars. Questions remain whether he prefers the period of history when the Russians were at the helm of the Soviet empire, or of Imperial Russia. Recent hostilities with former Soviet republic Georgia underscore the need to have a coherent policy towards Russia.
  5. Sino−Ruso−Iranian Alliance − Currently, the administration pits these countries together, in effect a sort of Axis of Evil. Except the rhetoric is not nearly as strong and the threat is much larger than the original Axis of Evil. But is this a natural alliance of an alliance of convenience? Is it a case of “the enemy of my enemy is my friend”? Moreover, is this a sustainable alliance that will pose a growing and continued threat to the United States?
  6. Afghanistan and Pakistan − The job was never finished in Afghanistan; the Taliban and al Qaeda were removed from power and decimated, but not destroyed. They’ve regrouped in Pakistan. Osama bin Laden is still considered to be alive. There is a weak central government in Afghanistan that is increasingly corrupt. Additionally, the Pakistani government has not been helpful in finding the terrorists in their mountainous regions, and American incursion into Pakistani territory has sparked several firefights in the last few weeks.
  7. Decreasing Hegemonic Status − The US has stretched its military might been economically irresponsible over the last eight years. As a result, we are no longer in position to be the sole major power in the world. The EU, while politically unstable, has seen its economy grow in the same time period. Both China and India have extremely large and fast growing economies. The course of the last eight years, unilateralism, is no longer tenable. The United States will need to figure out how to live in a post−American world where there are rising regional powers. The US will need to learn how to adapt to this new world.
  8. The War on Terror −If this war still exists (it’s hard to tell in these ever changing times) needs a new strategy. Because of our presence in Iraq, a new generation of radical Muslims have been trained in using guerilla tactics in fighting a major military power, much like al Qaeda in Afghanistan in the 1980s. A new strategy, including but not limited to military means, is needed to combat what has been done in the last eight years.
  9. The Middle East − Israel is the target of increasingly hostile rhetoric from Iran, which is attempting to assert itself in the region by becoming a nuclear power and influencing the Shi’a in Iraq. At the same time, Israel was less than easily victorious in its last incursion into Lebanon to fight Hezbollah, also backed by Iran. Finally, the US had called for democratic elections in Palestine, which catapulted anti−Israel Hamas to power. How does the United States act towards a democratically elected government that has interests contra American interests?
  10. Latin America −The triumvirate of Hugo Chavez, Raul Castro, and Evo Morales have produced a lot of anti−American rhetoric, but don’t pose too much of a threat. However, improving relations in Latin America is extremely important, as there are large amounts of Americans of Latin descent and three important economies − Mexico, Brazil, and Argentina − are situated there.
  11. Dependence on Oil − This issue is not just a foreign policy issue. Our dependence on foreign soil leaves us open to wild market fluctuations based on global demand, leaves at the mercy of OPEC, which includes many countries who aren’t exactly thrilled at us, as well as helps fill the coffers of many countries that are currently anti−American. However, it is not possible to wean ourselves off foreign oil and replace it with domestic produced oil, and this means the US needs to wean itself off of oil entirely.
  12. The War on Drugs − This may seem like an odd inclusion to my list, but it’s an important one. The prohibition of drugs does nothing to fight the demand of drugs, only the supply. And a demand for something with a prohibited supply creates a black market, which are, of course, illegal. Because of black market demand, terrorist organizations are able to fund their efforts by dealing in drugs. Examples are the Taliban in Afghanistan with opium and heroin production and FARQ in Columbia with cocaine. See also the PIRA in the 1980s who distributed drugs in order to fund their campaign against Britain. If we’re going to seriously attempt to squash terrorism, it’s necessary to seriously attack how they fund their actions. Having a realistic policy about drugs that treats people like adults rather than as children who cannot make decisions is one effective way to hurt terrorists, fight crime, and increase government income all at the same time.
  13. A Grand Strategy − A Grand Strategy for American foreign policy has been missing since the end of the Cold War. Prior, it was George Keenan and Harry Truman’s policy of Containment. Sure, Bush tried to have the policy of Prevention be the Grand Strategy, but this didn’t work in the first instance of use and is not a tenable long-term strategy. America needs to decide what its values are and how to best promote these values.